The title of today’s post is the bullsh*t line most people hear during a break up in between the other bullsh*t lines of “It’s not you, it’s me” and “I’d rather have you as a friend than not in my life at all.” (I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.) Unless one of the parties in the relationship commits an unforgivable, egregious relationship ending offense (i.e. pledging Delta), there’s usually an attempt to remain friends or at least stay friendly. After all the Carl Thomas, Mary J. and Neyo tracks have been played, can exes really be just friends?
I think to answer this question, you first have to answer the question of whether or not males and females can truly be platonic friends. (Platonic – a friendship where one party wouldn’t f*ck the daylights out of the other party if given the opportunity). Perhaps in college where you have a larger circle of friends that you actually kick it with, it’s more likely to have a platonic friend here or there (read: person you have not had a chance to f*ck yet). But as time passes and your inner circle gets whittled down to a select few, it’s more likely that any folks of the opposite sex that you frequently interact with are either professional contacts, romantic interests or a friend of a friend (read: f*cked/f*ckin’ one of your peoples). I don’t know too many dudes that call up their 5 best girlfriends to hit the club up, unless he’s attempting some sort of Jason Kidd-esque feat. On the other hand, there are a lot of females that do hang out with a lot of guys because they find women “catty”, but just keep in the back of your mind that 1 or more of the dudes in that group would f*ck you if given the opportunity. So while it may be possible to be platonic friends with someone, chances are physical attraction can and more than likely will over ride the desire for a platonic friend of the opposite sex.
That brings me back to the question of exes. As I just said, physical attraction between the sexes is undeniable. No matter how your relationship ended, there’s no denying that there was a mutual physical attraction between you and said ex, unless you’re one of those “I love her for what’s on the inside” people. Even then, if that’s what floats your boat, you’ll still be attracted to this person and keeping the friend door open is easy way to be constantly reminded of this fact. It’s real simple: unless you’re looking to get back with this person at some point, you really just can’t be friends. Just think about your relationship with a friend, whether it be of the same sex or someone of the opposite sex that you have a platonic relationship with (read: not your ex, not someone you have or desire to f*ck). Is it really feasible to have a stress free relationship with this person? Here’s how it breaks down….
What you want to happen: You break up with your SO and after all the tears and well wishes you guys eventually become BFF’s. This will be one of the people you can count on in your time of need because after all, you guys have been through so much and they “get” you. Your friendship will flourish into old age and this person will be Godparent to your child, a 3rd option babysitter, and your new SO’s friend as well.
Reality: “Let’s be friends” will be translated as “Let’s see if we can work this thing out”. Efforts to make preserve this relationship will be made in the form texts, phonecalls, email forwards, facebooking, tweets and the occaisonal “Let’s meet up for drinks”. Inevitably someone’s feelings will be re-kindled and an effort to jump start the relationship will be made by one party, which will be shot down by the other for whatever reason and said feelings will now be hurt.
Or…I could be wrong. But I doubt it.
Do you think you could be friends with an ex? Are you friends with an ex? How’s that working out for you…? I know a lot of you have run into this situation at least once, so holla at me. And if you were plannin’ to call your ex to hang out this weekend…think twice.
I burn bridges then destroy your city,

There's no hard and fast rules with anything is there? However, initially, I would say 'No' – when things are still raw, there's still feelings and division of assets and the reclaiming of stuff. But after a time – I don't see why not. You're both adults aren't you – and unless that person was a complete waste (in which case your choice in partner needs attention) they must have admirable qualities.
i TOTALLY agree. u can NOT be friends. oh you can try. you can try really hard. but the ish, in the end RARELY works out. instead, what you become is cordial. "my ex? oh yeah, we cool." but he doesn't get invited to your 30th birthday dinner or your christmas party. thus. he's not a real friend.
You bring up a good point. there are varying levels of friendships. Everyone isn't going to be there for the important stuff.
My initial response to this question is "Yes". I have platonic female friends that I have no desire to bang. Others, no desire but let the opportunity present itself…different story some (I think I'm j/k *shrug*)
As far as exes go, you have to know your boundaries. I still speak to all of my exes but not on a "hey lets hang out" level, primarily because we are in different cities but I can call them and hit them with the "How are things going" talk and in a sense, check up on them.
The funny thing with me is that if we say from jump we are going to try to be friends I'm cool with that and I put up my own boundaries. I'm not extending beyond they occasional hellos and if we hang out its usually in a group of folks. Very rarely will I be around you one-on-one, even if I know my side of things, I'm not gonna put myself in a position to screw up.
Besides, at this point in my life I have no desire to act like a little HS kid and act like you are the worst thing to ever happen to my life when we break up. I'm too old for that nonsense. We don't have to be together but I can be an adult and speak if we run into each other.
very, verrry well said.
Aw man, I guess I was on some HS shyt coz I hung out with my ex on a one-on-one basis many a time. He was my first love (I was 20) and he broke my heart….cheated on me with 2 females (that I know of) and one of them was my "friend". I didn't talk to him for 5 years. When we started talking I'd hang out with him, make him take me expensive restaurants and basically spend big bucks on me. And he didn't even get a hug LOL. I did it because I knew he thought that I'd give him another chance which was as likely to happen as 50 cent becoming the next POTUS lol
I wonder what's going on today that everyone is talking about exes. You can always try and be friends. It works out for some and not for the rest of us. Like someone once said, "Ain't my cup of tea so I won't even bother taking a sip."
I've tried and failed. What's the point of still being friends sometimes? If it's just to slap skin, then by all means booboo. But if it's to waste time and leave room for meaningless small talk, be gone.
Great post My innermost desires. 🙂
My ex tried this whole "I wanna be friends with you" thing as his deployment got closer. I told him it wouldn't work out and he kept going on these rants via text about how he'd be "willing to work hard" to restore it b/c I was "too good of a friend to lose." After I didn't see him I wished him the best of luck on his deployment and deleted all his text. Unless you all never got to that intimate stage of your relationship it's not possible to be just "friends" with an ex. There will be a day when the idea of getting it in one more time for ol' times sake crosses your mind.
"Unless you all never got to that intimate stage of your relationship it’s not possible to be just “friends” with an ex. There will be a day when the idea of getting it in one more time for ol’ times sake crosses your mind."
This.
I've tried it. Everything was cool for a while, then WHAM-POW-BOOM, feelings returned. While me and this particular ex are still "friends" to this day, we've had just one actual conversation in the past several months. Not because we hate each other or anything, but the dynamics of the relationship have been changed to where it's more of a casual friendship. Most of the time, that's the way the cookie crumbles and in the end it's better that way.
I don't speak to exes. Not because I hate them, and not because I'm trying to avoid slipping back in bed with them, but because I become no longer interested. If you're not going to be that person I'm spending the rest of my life with – I don't see a point in communicating. I don't need small talk, I do enough of that at work.
If I see you I'll say hey, but I'm not going to text, call, friend you on facebook (which is really just a ploy to be nosey anyway) or contact you because there is no benefit. It may sound callous, but it's worked for me thus far.
THIS!
Pretty much.
I'm really good friends with one of my ex's for close to 20 yrs…we just check in on each other via phone every so often….we don't really hang out. I would though. He's recently going thru a divorce so I am distancing myself until that is over. However, I have been an ear for him thru this because I have been there and I know you need a support network. I genuinely care about him but the romantic aspect is dead.
My ex husband, I literally cannot stand. I don't even like him let alone…want to be friends. The sad part is we have kids together and we were once really close…but, ever since he did all his dirt I am done. I hope maybe in another 15 yrs we could be friendly but as soon as I try to be friendly..he puts another dagger in my back..so. I don't trust him. Only for the sake of our kids do I even contemplate being friendly with him..but, we are civil.
Do I think ex's can be friends? Yes, from afar. I know my other ex would smash given the opportunity..but, I don't even think about. So, I keep a safe distance because I know he still may carry some feelings for me…its always either one or the other still carrying a torch…and sometimes both.
"So, I keep a safe distance because I know he still may carry some feelings for me…its always either one or the other still carrying a torch…and sometimes both."
Feelings? Or a hard d!ck? There's a big difference. For whatever reason it's so much easier to sleep with someone that you've already slept with. That's not feelings, that's convenience and ego ("I can still tap that anytime I want").
No shots, just saying….
Do you think you could be friends with an ex?
Yes, I'm at least cool with all my ex's, and I've remained pretty close to some ex's, but I think that was the nature of my past breakups–usually because of relocation. So are we friends, do we catch up, talk on the weekly/monthly bases, have drinks when we're both back at home or in each cities, yes.
Are you friends with an ex?
Yes.
How’s that working out for you…?
We share good memories, and we both can appreciate what we had. It's just cool. We both are involved with others, and we can talk about that relationship. My ex's and I are really good friends come to think about it.
And if you were plannin’ to call your ex to hang out this weekend…think twice.
…we talk every other day, …I guess its weird, but I was really good friends before we started dating. #kanyeshrug
this was what I was going to write.
One of my exes and I are thick as thieves. I was his best (wo)man at his wedding and even his wife and I chat. Granted we were great friends before we dated and dating was just a walk to horrible town.
My 2nd to last ex and I probably talk 2-3 times a week. He's my go to when stuff goes wrong or right. No b.s. I actually think he's a great person inside and I'm secure in our mutual decision to end our relationship.
Yes, there are times where you don't talk, but people forget there was a reason you first fell for them. If you're dating people for the right reasons, and their character is solid, you can at least be "cool."
Exactly. I was one of the first people my ex told when she found out she was pregnant. Like, it was her bf, her parents, and then me. We've always been able to talk about whatever since we first met. I had to make sure this dude was about the right things with here because if he wasn't it was going to be trouble for him.
I still check on her every few weeks to make sure the pregnancy is going normally and to see how she's doing overall.
Do you think you could be friends with an ex?
IMO, it depends on the situation. Yes, if everyone is mature enough to handle possibly seeing the other person moving on. Maybe not hanging out, going to catch a movie type friends, but I will be there if I am needed. However, No, if someone still has feelings.
Are you friends with an ex? No
How’s that working out for you…? N/A
I think the answer would depend on the situation. As far as males and females being platonic friends, I am not so sure. The one dude I do consider a friend, is always trying to smack me on the booty.
I get over a person easier if I do not deal with them on ANY level for a while so becoming friends at first would be out of the question for me.
I always tell folk that being friends w/ an ex… and my friend, I mean FRIEND… not acquaintance or casual text buddy… is based on if you were friends prior to the relationship. If Johnita and ShaQuan got together b/c there was a physical attraction between them, they dated… they ended. It'll be hard for them to form a friendship post-relationship b/c most likely at least one party would secks the other party if given the chance. Their relationship was first based on a mutual attraction. However if Johnita and ShaQuan have been friends since the 5th grade and in college they try to date, it doesn't work… they end it; I belive they have a chance. Relationships that were founded on friendships first have a higher chance of surviving post-breakup in my experience b/c the parties involved were friends first. They appreciate each other for more than the attraction… the attraction may be there but that's not what held them together before the dating. In other words the attraction isn't as big a part of the relationship between as it would be for other couples.
Am I friends with an ex? While I'd like to say yes, I truly think the answer is no. I don't have 1 ex that I speak to as a friend. I have 1 that I text semi-regularly and another that that I check in on monthly or so.
Well said So Flyy! You have VERY valid points about being "true" friends prior to the romantic relationship. I adore one of my exs to this day because we were friends first. I'd leave work right now if he called needing my help and I know he would do the same. He is a wonderful individual
and although it does get tricky sometimes because he is finethat I want to keep in my corner."Relationships that were founded on friendships first have a higher chance of surviving post-breakup in my experience b/c the parties involved were friends first. They appreciate each other for more than the attraction… the attraction may be there but that’s not what held them together before the dating."
very well said. still there needs to be time/space between to get over hurt feelings, if the breakup wasn't amicable.
I'm cordial to all of my exes. not necessarily friends because for many we no longer have anything in common. But I do have guy friends that I may have tried to date, it went wrong and we went back to being friends…
Somebody's trying to go for another award…
Well said, the initial friendship is paramount.
Clap, clap, bravo.
I've TRIED. lawd knows I TRIED and for awhile me and the Ex were cool so I thought.
We would kick it like Goodfellas laugh joke around even hang out it even got to the point he would confide in me about his boo & random chicks issues he was going through and me being A Friend would listen and give unbias advice when asked my opinion… #NoLie!!!
Our friendship began its demise when I started dating again……. He didn't want to lend an ear when I needed a male prospective on issues — okay no problem I let that slide then he starting catching attitudes sometimes he would curse me out and everything when I went on dates and apologize later for it and again I let it slide.
It got to the point for a minute I had to date on the low– Crazy I know!!!! #don'tJudgeMe
I had to end our so called Friendship because I realized it wasn't truly a friendship on his part — he was doing it moreso out of control than anything else. He wanted to keep me close, monopolize all my free time.
Sidenote: Oh and he went bat shyte crazy when he saw my date leaving my house one morning. *smh*
BUT I THOUGHT WE WERE FRIENDS…. #bbmcomfused
"Our friendship began its demise when I started dating again……. He didn’t want to lend an ear when I needed a male prospective on issues — okay no problem I let that slide then he starting catching attitudes sometimes he would curse me out and everything when I went on dates and apologize later for it and again I let it slide. "
WHAT IS THIS ABOUT?? Some XY PLEASE tell me! Simply pride? Jealousy? Over what? You didn't want me, remember?
Confused right there with you!
I found one of my exes on FB and after a bit of awkwardness we buried old hatchets and talk now on a regular basis. She's married w/ two kids and just recently moved to my area. I let her know I'd always be just a phone call or email away…JUST TO TALK and luckily we've been pretty cool with one another.
I think it just takes a sense of maturity from both parties and you'll be fine….
"Talking" is how it starts Eddie. Is she still hot?…I ask only because black don't crack…Watchyaself! 😀
Um…..not exactly. Both of us have changed but one of us [the one with the ovaries] changed a little more. And you're right, there was some serious flirting going on when we first began talking because she was seriously considering leaving her husband and sort of hinted that if I wanted "it" I could have "it".
Long story short, her husband was suffering from PTSD and I helped convince her to stick it out and try and get him the help he needed.
Besides, I'm not now nor have I ever been a cheater…..
That warms mi corazon Eddie that you didn't take her up on her advances. You did the right thing and not everyone would have. Keeping a "friendly" distance is a good look.
I think it just takes a sense of maturity from both parties and you’ll be fine….
I agree with this… Buuuuut
Not only maturity but both parties' feelings/emotions needs to be in check as well.
Agree + cosign + yuuup
:0P
In general I don't believe in being friends with my exes but I do have a friendship with my last ex that is similar to the ideal friendship you described…the romantic feelings are gone on both sides but we love each other and he's my go-to person when I need help – I even wrote a post celebrating him as the ideal ex. He's great.
That being said, even though we have what I consider to be the plationic ideal of ex-friendships, it's still a slippery slope. Just yesterday he called me to complain about an issue he's having with his wife and I was just like….this is not cool. On the one hand he's going through things and I want to be there for him, but on the other hand it's outrageously disrespectful to be discussing your marital issues with your ex-girl. The whole thing was so frustrating that when I got off the phone I was like "See? THIS is why you're not supposed to be friends with your ex!".
In all optimism he may feel really comfortable around you. Trust me he is going to have a few folks he is going to vent to. He may be looking at you as a friend while you are looking at him as an ex.
Yes I'm pulling at straws here but its not impossible.
I've talked to one of my exes about a more recent ex (at the time) and she helped me a ton to decide how to go about a situation.
Oh I don't doubt that his intentions are innocent enough…he's looking for someone whom he can trust to talk to about something personal and I get that. But still I think it's inappropriate. And although his wife is cool with our friendship, I'm pretty sure she would not be pleased if she knew about it.
Max.
IMO I think he's coming to you in hopes of getting a female perspective on his issues and since you two have history and are now strictly platonic you are his GO 2 GIRL…. but if you really feel it's inappropriate then maybe you should talk to him about it and set some boundaries in regards to the friendship. #justsayin
Max, I agree with Girl6. If it's a problem, definitely discuss it with him. He maybe coming to you because you know him and can give him a true prospective from a woman's point of view–a woman who has been in a relationship with him and not from a friend who will not be able to see the entire picture. Its a big difference being a friend with a man and being the girlfriend of the same man. You have both prospectives to offer.
interesting post. this is all i have to add:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8TnhNxKNlU
The criteria to be my friend is much more lax than the criteria to be my man. Just because he couldn't hack in in the boyfriend slot, doesn't disqualify him for the friend position.
I will absolutely need a period of time completely away from him to readjust to living my life as a single woman. Readjusting to not having his emotional and physical support on tap. But once we've gotten back into our grooves away from each other. I see no problem in being friends, in theory. The thing is you sorta expect that once you're friends again that things will be just like they were, just no sex. But they'll never be the same, relationships are about oh so much more than sex. That's what we can't seem to wrap our heads around.
Here's my thing…just because I'm attracted to you and would like to jump your bones doesn't mean that I will act on those feelings. So yes, if I wanted you before I may want you again, but I know that "we" don't work out for whatever reason so I suppress those urges.
You know how many dudes I wanna violate on a weekly basis? But I'm a laday!This is much easier said than done, especially if you're both having flashbacks at the same time.I do have a quasi successful ex to friend, but our "relationship" was quite limited and our friendship, although deep, is very infrequent in terms of times spent. And I total envision effing him when we talk. *shrug*
So I'm still riding the fence on this question…
What ever your looking for in a relationship with a person you will get with respect. Its not hard to maintain good relationships if you consider yourself a positive person. You are in control of your space, so if you want to be more than friends with your ex you will. If you really don't want the intimacy it won't happen. People hide behind titles to say what they really want. The word EX is a secret code for We will have SEX again, because we are familiar with each other. So, its your choice who you keep as your Ex! Think about it!
I think it depends on the breakup and the nature of "why". if it was one of those "agree to disagree and end it" type of deals maybe. If grimy shyt went down, I'd say no. Im quick to cutoff "friends" that do me wrong, so why would I make an exception for a woman i had feelings for/was my gf?
also, i think its much easier for the "person who initiated the breakup" to be more open to friendship than the "dump-ee"
Im not going to force anything personally. I can be cordial and civil, but I wont be a get out of jail free card to any past lover. sorry.
For the majority of my exes, I would say, no, we couldn't be friends. If I don't trust the EX enough to be my man, I sure won't trust him to be my friend.
I am friends with one EX and that's only because we actually make better friends than we did a couple. We actually still have the trust factor and actually care about what happens to the other. But there's no romantic feelings on either one of our parts for the other.
I have had guys tell me they think it's weird to have any contact with exes, which I've thought about extensively. I've never remained close friends with an ex, but we're cool. Once I've resolved everything in my own mind, occasionally running into people doesn't bother me at all. I think it's possible, but it depends on the personalities of people involved. Some people can handle it for themselves, but not for their partner and vice versa. These situations have me questioning two things: one; are you actually over this person (and if you're not, why are you in a new relationship?) & two; what sort of trust issues do you have with your partner?
Generally, I don't do well with ex's in my immediate space, immediately after a break up. I need time to process and unattach myself from everything, and when I don't it just leaves room for potential issues that I don't want to deal with especially if one person is still trying to 'fix' things.
Unless one of the parties in the relationship commits an unforgivable, egregious relationship ending offense (i.e. pledging Delta)
^^^I definitely said out loud "oh sh*t son" when i read that line (#ShotsFired)
Do you think you could be friends with an ex?
^^^Depends
Are you friends with an ex?
^^^Yes
How’s that working out for you…?
^^^We are in different states so its going alright.
This post hit home, not cause of the ex thing but just being platonic friends…it was definitely a struggle for me but i don't think it will be anymore.
Great post!